HomeAdviceBuyingseller lied about roof leak
Go Back

seller lied about roof leak

we buy home 4 months ago. Inspection say roof is okay. Now big rain and water come in kitchen ceiling. I call seller and he say 'not my problem.' Can I make him pay for fix?

Asked by Jose | Joliet, IL| 04-22-2026| 22 views|Buying|Updated 6 days ago

Answers (6)

Sort by:
Keith Jean Pierre

REMAX First Realty · East Brunswick, NJ

(151 reviews)
Jose, most likely, the burden of proof would be on you to prove fraud and that the seller knew about the issue and covered it up. It is best to speak to a real estate attorney to get an understanding of your options and none of us on here can give you legal advice. Best of luck with the situation. Keith Jean-Pierre Managing Principal The Dapper Agents Operations In: NY, NJ, FL & CA
View Profile
04-23-2026 (5 days ago)··
Michael KozlowskiSemi-Pro80 Answers
Michael Kozlowski

RE/MAX Professionals · Littleton, CO

(131 reviews)
Jose You may want to reach out the real estate agent that helped you with your transaction and/or a local real estate attorney to review the disclosures in your transaction and find out what your rights are.
View Profile
04-26-2026 (3 days ago)··
Jennifer HupkeSemi-Pro30 Answers
Jennifer Hupke

RE/MAX Forward · New Berlin, WI

(136 reviews)
No, you can’t automatically make the seller pay. After closing, it’s your house, unless you can prove the seller knew about the leak and didn’t disclose it. Key questions: Did you get a disclosure report? Did it mention the roof or leaks? Do you have proof the seller knew and hid it? If not, this is likely your responsibility. Next step: Get a roofer out and document everything, then talk to a real estate attorney to see if you have a case. Bottom line, without proof of non-disclosure, it’s an uphill battle.
View Profile
04-24-2026 (4 days ago)··
Find Agent CTA

Are you ready to find a top agent near you?

Browse profiles of the highest ranked agents in your area and find one that meets your specific needs.

Marc ComisarNovice5 Answers
Marc Comisar

Domain Realty · Bonita Springs, FL

You might have a case, but it depends on proof. If the seller knew about the leak and didn’t disclose it, that’s a problem and you could go after them. The challenge is proving they knew. Start by documenting everything and talk to a real estate attorney. Don’t rely on the seller to ‘do the right thing’ at this point.
View Profile
04-24-2026 (5 days ago)··
Marc ComisarNovice5 Answers
Marc Comisar

Domain Realty · Bonita Springs, FL

You might have a case, but it depends on proof. If the seller knew about the leak and didn’t disclose it, that’s a problem and you could go after them. The challenge is proving they knew. Start by documenting everything and talk to a real estate attorney. Don’t rely on the seller to ‘do the right thing’ at this point.
View Profile
04-24-2026 (5 days ago)··
Hans SoderquistNovice4 Answers
Hans Soderquist

Cornerpin · Ithaca, NY

(9 reviews)
This is no doubt very upsetting. If your inspection indicated no sign of active leaks it does not sound like you would be successful getting the seller to pay for repairs. In theory, the inspector has some liability if there were in fact signs of an active leak at the time of the inspection. This is why inspectors carry errors and omissions insurance. Take a close look at your inspection photos and speak to an attorney to understand better what your remedies might be if the inspector made a mistake.
View Profile
04-24-2026 (5 days ago)··
Find Agent CTA

Are you ready to find a top agent near you?

Browse profiles of the highest ranked agents in your area and find one that meets your specific needs.

Related Questions

I am 72. Can I still buy a house?

Asked by Rose Marie Dudley | 72301 | 23 views | Buying | 04-27-2026 | Updated 21 hours ago

Found mold in the crawlspace

Asked by Lindy | Cleveland, OH | 0 views | Buying | 04-27-2026 | Updated 2 days ago

Agent won't show me houses without preapproval?

Asked by Greg | Lake Forest, IL | 13 views | Buying | 04-27-2026 | Updated 2 days ago

Is 550 credit score enough for a loan?

Asked by Martin | Lubbock, TX | 14 views | Buying | 04-27-2026 | Updated 2 days ago

Why do I have to pay property taxes on a condo or a villa?

Asked by Pamela M Rogers | Toledo, OH | 13 views | Buying | 04-24-2026 | Updated 5 days ago